General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAndrew Gillum's Win Is Great News for All Democrats--Despite What the Media May Tell You
Andrew Gillums Win Is Great News for All DemocratsDespite What the Media May Tell You
Three weeks ago, the media declared the left vanquished. With the Florida results, they flipped the scriptand got it wrong again.
By Joan Walsh
There they go again.
Just three weeks ago, the mainstream political media reported that the broad Democratic left was divided, and that the so-called establishment wing had defeated the forces of Senator Bernie Sanders. The evidence? Mainly that in Michigan, Gretchen Whitmer beat Sanders-endorsed Abdul El-Sayed in the gubernatorial primary, while in Kansas, Sharice Davids topped another Our Revolution favorite, Brett Welder, for a congressional nomination. I argued at the time that progressives, defined broadly, had in fact won the night: Its ridiculous to define women like Whitmer, who supports a $15 minimum wage, gun-safety legislation, and Planned Parenthood funding, or Native American lesbian Obama administration veteran Davids, as merely establishment.
This time, the script is flipped, but the divisive storyline is the same.
Now the Sanders forces supposedly have the establishment on the run, with the surprise victory of Tallahassee Mayor Andrew Gillum in a crowded Democratic primary race. But again, thats the wrong takeaway from an exciting primary. Gillum was an early Hillary Clinton surrogate and convention delegate whose victory is first and foremost due to the hard work of African-American Democrats, the backbone of the party. The Gillum beats the establishment storylines are creating a false narrative, maybe even intentionally so.
Black Democrats bet on Gillum early, when most observers didnt think he had a chance. BlackPAC and Color of Change went all-in last spring; the Sanders endorsement came in August. It was particularly meaningful since Gillum had been a prominent Clinton surrogate. As he did with Stacey Abrams, a black Clinton supporter who won the gubernatorial primary in Georgia, Sanders showed an ability to move beyond the fissures of 2016 that others in the party, on both sides, appear to lackand that the media will forever use to write their favorite (and laziest) storyline, Dems in disarray.
https://www.thenation.com/article/andrew-gillums-win-is-great-news-for-all-democrats-despite-what-the-media-may-tell-you/
NCTraveler
(30,481 posts)David__77
(23,421 posts)I hope a good progressive unity emerges, against white supremacy and all that comes with it.
mcar
(42,334 posts)after 2 years of racism and sexism as US policy.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)..."identity politics" as key to winning. That's what separates the likes of Kamala Harris from the likes of Bernie Sanders or Tim Ryan. It's less about establishment vs. progressive, which is really a false dichotomy. Ryan might be considered establishment while Sanders might be considered progressive, but they both subscribe to the white working class economic anxiety/anti-identity politics narrative. Harris and other Dems don't.
mcar
(42,334 posts)WRT Democratic policies that support human rights. The Republicans play identity politics, not Democrats.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)...buy into the notion that it's all about appealing to white economic anxiety.
Voltaire2
(13,061 posts)In general the progressive candidates are all Also strong supporters of equality.
The centrist candidates are stuck in the 90s on economic issues. By the way framing Medicare for All and 15 and the rest of the economic justice issues of the left as white issues is bullshit.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)...was this idea that working class white people voted for Trump due to economic anxiety, that Clinton was too focused on "identity politics," and that racism and sexism only played a minor role in the rise of Trump. Article after article pushed that narrative, and Sanders embraced it.
That narrative was and still is absurd.
mcar
(42,334 posts)I remember it well. So short sighted and just plain damn wrong!