General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsConspiratorial fear mongering about cell phones and cancer, courtesy of The Nation
There was a thread about cell phones and brain cancer here last week. The always excellent David Gorski (Orac) weighs in again on the topic.
https://respectfulinsolence.com/2018/04/09/more-fear-mongering-about-cell-phones-cancer/
The latest magazine to publish a sensationalistic story about cell phones is The Nation. Amusingly, someone in The Nations PR department thought it would be a good idea to send me a link a week ago, as though I might blog about it. Of course, Im happy to oblige, because this story is an example of much of what is wrong with reporting on the issue of cell phones and health effects due to cell phone radiation. Written by Mark Hertsgaard and Mark Dowie and entitled How Big Wireless Made Us Think That Cell Phones Are Safe: A Special Investigation. Its tagline? The disinformation campaignand massive radiation increasebehind the 5G rollout. The basic thesis of the article is that big wireless is a lot like big tobacco in hiding the science or preventing definitive science from being done because, presumably, it has something to hide. Its the very same sort of argument that antivaxers like to make about big pharma and vaccines, likening vaccine manufacturers to big tobacco and claiming the same sort of disinformation campaign that big tobacco waged for decades to hide, minimize, and obfuscate the emerging scientific evidence of the harm cigarette smoking was causing through causing lung cancer, heart disease, and a variety of other diseases.
No one, least of all I, is claiming that big telecom and big pharma are pristine, as clean as the driven snow. We do know from science, however, that vaccines do not cause autism and that cell phone radiation not only does not cause the health effects attributed to it but almost certainly cannot cause those health effects because the energy carried by radio waves is too low to do what is claimed. Its basic physics. For instance, I like to say that, although a link between cell phone radiation and cancer is not homeopathy-level implausible, it is incredibly implausible, simply because most of mechanisms of carcinogenesis we know involve as an inciting event the breaking of chemical bonds in DNA to cause mutations, and even the mechanisms were coming to understand that might require chemical bond breakage as an inciting event are incredibly unlikely to be impacted by such low energy waves.
Enter The Nation.
Gorski writes a detailed commentary, with dozens of links to prior research and articles. It's a long read, but well worth the time.
Sid
hlthe2b
(102,287 posts)But, the direction it has gone the past several years, especially with her Russia-loving apologist husband pushing her ever more into a Dennis Kucinich-like position. Ummm, no. I'm done
Dr Hobbitstein
(6,568 posts)Seems it comes up every couple of years... I guve it all the consideration it deserves.
Achilleaze
(15,543 posts)I feel subtle, uncomfortable vibes in my ears and head when I hold the cell phone close while talking. It's a definite and unnatural feeling.
Science - whether corporately funded or otherwise - can tell me that their tests prove such sensations are cool and unharmful. Thank you for the input. But I will not dishonor my own perceptions, nor would I ever abuse anyone else for using their own intelligence to make their own decisions. That's free will right there, and it deserves respect. If it's time to use a cellphone, I always employ the speakerphone or ear buds.
SidDithers
(44,228 posts)Achilleaze
(15,543 posts)If that's what does it for you, ok. But I'm just not into vinegar.
SidDithers
(44,228 posts)That I can swallow the denier "it's perfectly normal" BS -- or I can use my own faculties.
Huh.
Now, please post something about scientific materialism. And chemtrails. Chemtrail threads are always fun.
Sid
Achilleaze
(15,543 posts)the fumes are clouding your mind.
Progressive dog
(6,904 posts)than the "vaccines cause autism" crap. Not having a cell phone is unlikely to kill you or those who have to depend on herd immunity.