I won't ask who won - that is one of those "depends upon how you define
won". Palin beat her abysmally low expectations. She knows how to speak in
generalities, buzzwords and talking points - this will please the Republican base (that is their native language.) Palin is unlikely to impress the intelligentsia, either left or right. Biden played it safe and that was probably wise. Why take any risk when you are so far ahead?
What I think one should look at are the likely effects of the debate.
1) no significant
SNL moments to embarrass the McCain/Palin campaign
2)
reassure those who had major doubts among the
McCain base voters
3)
no change in momentum for the election - she did neither harm nor good
One way to
access the likely results is to view the
Intrade political futures after the debate:
1) Sarah Palin to be withdrawn as Republican VP nominee/candidate before 2008 presidential election?
Before debate: 9.9%
After debate: 4.5%
2) John McCain to win 2008 US Presidential Election?
Before debate: 35.6%
After debate: 33.2%
By this measure, Palin helped herself (a pattern) a lot but did absolutely nothing for improving the prospects for the McCain/Palin campaign.