Best QB

[Champ]

[Birthmark]

1. Brady, hands down.

His statistics are good and he's won the Big One. None of the others have.

[sportndandy]

2. Donovan over Brady

And the proof is coming in 2 and one half weeks. See ya in Jacksonville.

[mark414]

3. mcnabb

if brady wasn't as smart as he is he'd be a terrible quarterback; he's not very big and his arm is average; mcnabb has the smarts and the pure physical strength and stamina to go along with it

edited to say i'm a packers fan...so i SHOULD hate the guy, but he still blows my mind

[MrSlayer]

4. Brady, he's got the rings.

McNabb is next and the other two aren't ready for prime time yet.

[DaveinMD]

5. this isn't even close

Brady all the way. Already two super bowl victories, incredible accuracy, great decision making and he can make every throw.

[Ekirh]

6. Of the four choices...

I have to go with Brady...

I Like Mcnabb and vick.. but Brady earns his paycheck during the playoffs

7-0 (I'm predicting 8-0 after this weekend... here's hoping I won't be eating Humble pie on that prediction).... 2 Superbowl rings in a short span.. and two super bowl M.V.Ps.

Now if we only were talking regular season... and not regular season/playoffs (Which I'm going to assume we are) I might pick differently... but considering how deep we are in the playoffs at this point.. you just can't chose better than Brady right now.

[CatholicEdHead]

7. Culpepper

[Champ]

8. This isn't in the league

Donovan
Culpepper
Manning

would be my top options with players like Vick, Farve, Brady, Green, Pennington, Plummer, Brees would round out the poll. Those are the best best QBs in the league, stats from them the last 3-4 years with Vick's numbers are low but when he plays his team wins. He greatly change defensive gameplans which impact the outcome of the game.

[Champ]

9. My vote goes to McNabb

Did Brady throw 4 Touchdown passes on a broken ankle? McNabb is obviously the best QB on Conference Championship Sunday. Marino is better then atleast 95% of all QBs of all time and he has no rings.