I found an interesting correlation between the post debate polls and the word count of the participants.
Number of words spoken:
1) Senator Obama - 1,872
2) Senator Clinton - 1,766
3) Senator Edwards - 1,518
4) Governor Richardson - 1,281
5) Representative Kucinich - 1,180
6) Senator Biden - 961
7) Senator Dodd - 912
8) Senator Gravel - 753
Source:
http://www.pollster.com/mystery_pollster/tag_clouds_for_the_democratic.phpWho won the debate:
1) Obama 31%
2) Clinton 24%
3) Edwards 14%
4) Biden 6%
5) Richardson 4%
6) Kucinich 3%
7) Dodd 2%
8) Gravel 2%
9) Not Sure 13%
Source:
http://www.surveyusa.com/client/PollReport.aspx?g=ba1ebc70-a734-4185-8532-2e4a9ba45d96&q=39848Notice that there is a considerable correlation between how much time a candidate got to speak and whether or not that person was perceived to have "won" the debate. The exceptions are Biden, who did slightly better than his word count would indicate, and Kucinich, who did slightly worse. Given that the number of words a candidate gets to speak is in no small part determined by the moderator, it's no wonder these types of debates merely serve to solidify the top tier candidates. That, after all, is what the media wants: a smaller race that is cheaper to cover.