Did Judy Miller lie during the trial to help Libby because she had sex with him?

[antiimperialist]

I don't know, but it occured to me that the quote about the aspens attributed to Libby in a letter to Judy was weird. What if them too had sexual encounters?

Miller recently said in her testimony that she might have spoken to other reporters about Plame, but she does not remember.

Judy may be trying to undermine her own credibility to help her ex-lover.

It sounds to me like she is full of it, and won't say names because they would deny the false charges.

[theoldman]

1. I guess I have to ask, just where did you get the information

that they had sex?

[antiimperialist]

They met in Jackson Hole, Wyoming

Do any of those two live anywhere closet to Wyoming?

[antiimperialist]

12. Who said it was information?

It's speculation.

[PresidentObama]

2. Is DU turning into the tabloids?

[Fresh_Start]

3. I didn't get the idea that Miller testimony aided Libby

why do you think it did?

[antiimperialist]

5. The fact that she claims to have bad memory helps Libby

Because the argument about Libby is that you can't forget having discussed an issue of such importance as the Valerie Plame issue.

[Fresh_Start]

10. But she didn't claim to have a bad memory

she claimed to have a note-driven memory. When she sees her notes, it revives her memory. Her notes didn't support Libby.

[goodhue]

4. But her testimony didn't help him

[MonkeyFunk]

6. of course

because no woman could ever attain a prominent position without sleeping her way there. See the countless threads on Condi.

Your supposition is sexist and insulting.

[antiimperialist]

8. The fact that I don't believe Condi slept with anyone debunks your theory

I even have my doubts about her being heterosexual.

Is that sexist too?

[MonkeyFunk]

9. the fact is

it's been said here repeatedly that Condi is fucking Bush.

Now, with absolutely NO evidence whatsoever, it's proposed that Miller was fucking Libby. Zero evidence. Just the sexist notion that there has to be SOME explanation to explain her success and access beyond her natural talents.

[antiimperialist]

11. And do you have evidence to call it sexist?

Judith Miller achieved prominence long ago, after winning a Pullitzer prize and many other achievements. For your theory to be valid, I would have had to infer that she slept with SEVERAL men in order to get where she is.
And a sexist man would be sexist against all women. Why am not accusing Condi of having sex with anyone?

[MonkeyFunk]

15. I'm not accusing you

of saying that about Rice.

I'm saying many people here do, and I find the presumption sexist. Similarly, I think that supposing that Miller slept with Libby is sexist. As evidence, I don't see you proposing that Pincus, or Woodward, or Novak, or Russert slept with Libby.

[Turbineguy]

7. Lying about sex

as we all know, is completely forbidden.

[Jack Rabbit]

13. I don't know and neither do you.

Leave that kind of speculation to dirty minds like Ken Starr's.

[Lint Head]

14. The Ass-Pins Have Turned