Now I can post a poll! Best all-time rock drummer?

[Phillycat]

Whew, got my star back; that feels better. Now I feel compelled to post a poll, since I can. Let's do an oldie but goodie. Who's the best all-time rock drummer? No jazz! The jazz drummers are always better. :)

[Phillycat]

1. What in heaven's name?

People in the lounge aren't into music anymore? :D

What if they held a poll and nobody came? :cry:

[dolo amber]

Yeah, the Lounge has changed

a lot in that respect. Too bad, too. :(

[Phillycat]

11. Well, that's just not gonna work.

We'll just have to talk to each other!! :D

[XNASA]

5. You're silly.

Drummers aren't musicians. :eyes:

[Phillycat]

10. LOL!

Dammit, of course you're right! At least they don't play the banjo...

[Magrittes Pipe]

22. If they played the banjo, they would not be musicians...

...they would be gods.

[immoderate]

71. The drummer is the musician's best friend!

--IMM

[begin_within]

74. The lounge needs to have streaming music.

[kwassa]

2. Mitch Mitchell of the Jimi Hendrix Experience

a very interesting drummer

[Phillycat]

3. He almost made the list!

I hate the 10-choice max!

Good call. :thumbsup:

[realisticphish]

4. I voted for Neil

but I would actually say Mike Portnoy of Dream Theater is better.

And Travis Barker may be fast, but he's not even CLOSE to the best drummer, stylistically or techinically

[Phillycat]

7. I think he's great and getting better

I think people will look back in 20 years and talk about him as one of the best of his era.

Mike Portnoy is always a contender. :thumbsup:

[realisticphish]

14. One thing I like about DT

is their ability to use silence. That is, pauses in music that are almost more effective than the parts with sound. Drums are CRUCIAL when it comes to deciding that kind of thing.

Not to mention, I love the little double bass riffs mike throws in here and there... he can pound away like a motherfucker, but he also knows how to be subtle.

[Magrittes Pipe]

6. Jaki Leibzeit.

:thumbsup:

[Phillycat]

12. From Can, right?

Good choice! :thumbsup:

[Magrittes Pipe]

16. Damn straight.

:bounce:

[WritingIsMyReligion]

8. I'm boycotting this poll.

The jazzers always ARE damn better.

:P :P

:hi:

[Phillycat]

15. Well, it's like...

having a greatest guitarist thread and including Jimi Hendrix. What's the point? There's Jimi, and then there's everyone else.

Anyway, my point was, if we were to include Krupa, Blakey, etc, it wouldn't be a fair fight. :hi:

I really did want to include ?uestlove, though. He's a beast. :)

[WritingIsMyReligion]

25. Yeah, the poll would be totally slanted.

:D

:hi:

[billyskank]

30. For that matter

the jazz guitarists are always better, too... ;)

[maveric]

64. You like Billy Cobham?

I saw him in 73 and he was mesmerizing.

[DS1]

9. Danny Carey

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danny_Carey

[Phillycat]

17. Oh yes, from Tool.

I think he is incredibly talented. However, I am not a Tool fan (that's a nice way of saying I can't stand that guy's voice) and so I don't get to hear him too often.

[SlavesandBulldozers]

21. 2nd vote for Danny Carey

runners up, for me, would be Matt Cameron and Mike "Puffy" Bordin.

from your list I'd have to pick Pert, but I selected other because Carey pretty much has no equal.

[alarcojon]

68. I like Carey a lot

but he's still behind Peart and Bruford for me.

[Broken_Hero]

13. My pick...:)

I voted other: I know you said best Rock Drummer, but I think, the best drummer I ever heard, is Raymond Herrera, the drummer for Fear Factory...

[Phillycat]

18. Huh, I've never heard him!

I will have to check it out. :)

If we were opening it up to non-rock, I would have definitely included ?uestlove, as I said above. The guy is a machine.

[Broken_Hero]

28. Yeah, i think

Herrera is pretty damn tough, consistant, speed, and hits the double bass pedals like his life depends on it. I was also thinking of the drummer of Dio(can't remember his name now to save my life, i think his first name was steve, or vinnie?)....I also like Slipknots drummer, but Herrera bounces around a WHOLE lot more....:)

[LynneSin]

19. John Bonham all the way with Roger Tayler of Queen #2

:D

[Phillycat]

23. Well, we KNEW what your number one would be! LOL!

Rodger Taylor is underrated simply because he was behind the greatest frontman in the history of rock music. How could you take your eyes off Freddie Mercury onstage? It's like, "Wait, there's a drummer back there?" :D

[LynneSin]

33. Crazy thing is, I liked Taylor's voice better than Mercury

He's done a bunch of lead vocals on the Queen albums but never given much chance to sing other than backup or doing the Bowie part for "Under Pressure"

That's why I'm so upset with the Queen+Paul Rodgers tour - why hire a lead singer when your bands best singer is playing the damn drums

[billyskank]

20. Who's that guy from Def Leppard?

;)

[Phillycat]

24. Seriously!

You don't see any of these other guys playing with one damned arm! :D

(His name is Rick Allen, by the way.)

[billyskank]

26. Right!

If he had two arms, he could play drums and send text messages at the same time! :D

Thanks for the reminder. :hi:

[Phillycat]

31. HAHAHA!

"i'm onstage. where r u?"

[billyskank]

35. ...

:rofl:

[SlavesandBulldozers]

67. lol

typed with his toes.

Here's to you Rick Allen . You fucking rock. :toast: <--look it's two Rick Allens. lol.

[AllegroRondo]

29. but can he play a roll?

[Phillycat]

32. Now that's just mean.

:thumbsup:

[AllegroRondo]

27. I had to vote for Neil, but....

an honorable mention goes to Tommy Lee. Motley Crue never really appealed to me, but his drumming is darn good.

Another honorable mention to "Future Man" of Bela Fleck's band. Frikin amazing stuff, but he does play it on a 'drumitar', a kind of electronic drum kit built into a guitar body. You really have to see him live to appreciate it.

[Phillycat]

34. Tommy Lee played the piss out of the drums

Much like Bonham, and later, Dave Grohl. Good pick. :thumbsup:

I've seen Bela's band, and while I'm not into the noodly nature of the music, I remember thinking that thing he was playing was amazing. :)

[WeRQ4U]

36. What about Steven Adler?

He wasn't overly talented, and he didn't do anything with a 3 brazillion piece drum set like Pert did, but he did usher in a trendy use of the cowbell as well as a patented floor tom/bass drum crescendo used in many rock pieces. He didn't invent either technique, but he perfected them. LOL.

I hope people know I'm kidding here.

[Phillycat]

37. MORE COWBELL

[Oeditpus Rex]

38. Ian Paice

of Deep Purple. Best I ever heard, anyway.

But then, I've heard a lot more Deep Purple than Cream. That's why I didn't vote for Ginger Baker, although he has the rep as the best.

The measure of a good drummer is not how hot he solos, but how well he punctuates the melody.

Gotta give a nod to Carl Palmer, too, although he had a kit the size of Ohio.



No... drum kit. :eyes:

[Phillycat]

39. Which is why I will always and forever vote for Stewart Copeland

He never. Made. A mistake. Ever. Always perfect. It's superhuman.

[Oeditpus Rex]

44. He'd probably tell ya different

Paice got the bass slightly out of synch for a nanosecond during his solo on "The Mule" on the "Made In Japan" live album. But what I always noticed about him was an uncanny knack for just the right cymbal and the right amount. That's part of what I meant by "punctuation."

He had ungodly stamina, too. I dunno how he got through 21 minutes of "Space Truckin'" on the live album — a lot of it riffs — with just one break during Blackmore's violin solo. Dude must've had Popeye arms.

[blindpig]

40. I voted for Bill Bruford but

John French, AKA Drumbo of the Magic Band is a monster. Listen to Mirror Man and dare dispute.......

[Phillycat]

41. I will check it out, not being familiar with his work!

Thanks for the tip. :thumbsup:

[Ohio Joe]

42. One minor nitpick

It is spelled Peart not Pert

[Phillycat]

43. Damn, just past the editing period.

Sorry! Thanks for the heads up. :)

[Beware the Beast Man]

45. Brant Bjork- Kyuss, Fu Manchu and a ton of other groups.

[Phillycat]

47. Hey, I remember Fu Manchu!

It was one of those bands where I was standing in a record store and they had it playing, and I was compelled to ask who it was because I liked it so well.

Will check him out! :thumbsup:

[RandomKoolzip]

46. George Hurley, The Minutemen.

[Phillycat]

48. Oh yeah!

Great choice. :thumbsup:

[leftofthedial]

49. Ringo is/was a greatly underappreciated drummer.

Steve Gadd is a great drummer, but perhaps crosses the jazz line.

Two LA session drummers are great, too--Jim Keltner and Russ Kunkel.

As you may have guessed, I voted for Charlie Watts in your poll.

I can't stand busy drummers. It's all about the groove and the song.

[Phillycat]

50. "Busy drummers" - that's a good phrase :)

I can't stand "noodly guitarists", so I know what you mean. :thumbsup:

[immoderate]

73. Ken Butrey!

Epitome of taste. Nashville session guy, backed Dylan, Al Kooper, many others.

--IMM

[jpgray]

51. Robert Wyatt

With working legs, anyway.

[Phillycat]

52. Eek!!!

Not a Floyd fan. :) But they were all good musicians.

[jpgray]

53. That's Nick Mason you're thinking of

And nobody should, in this thread.

[Phillycat]

54. Oops, then who the hell is Robert Wyatt?

How do I not know that name?

[jpgray]

58. With Soft Machine

Until they became a boring jazz fusion group they had some great tracks.

[Phillycat]

59. Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

Thanks! :hi:

[alarcojon]

69. Ouch!

Nick Mason is better than our current leader, Keith Moon, fer cryin' out loud!

How's that math problem going. Remember the hint I gave ya? ;-)

[underpants]

55. AaaNIiiiiMAL!

[Phillycat]

56. Well, he was the FIRST drummer I fell in love with.

It's those eyebrows... *swoon*

[jpgray]

57. Karl Burns should probably get a mention

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GPjHblXZQQ&search=the%20fall%20john%20peel

[Phillycat]

60. All right, I'm going to Ireland now. You kids have fun!

And remember, drummers aren't really musicians anyway. Xnasa said so. :hi:

[billyskank]

65. Bye!

:hi:

[Tikki]

61. Bun E. Carlos........n/t

[nytemare]

62. Phil Collins.

His most recent music has been pretty blah, but his early drumming with Genesis, and his early solo work was amazing.

[maveric]

63. Best "Rock" drummer? Moon. Best I've seen? Billy Cobham.

He played with John McGlauthin <sp> and the Mahavishnu Orchestra. As great as McGlauthin was, Cobham's drumming stole the show.

[Beaverhausen]

66. Alan White - played with Yes, John Lennon and others

[alarcojon]

70. Bruford was way better than White

and went on to do jazz.

[Coventina]

72. Gina Shock of the Go-Go's

Yeah, I said it.

I stand by it.

[begin_within]

75. What about Mitch Mitchell (oh sorry, just noticed someone else posted him)