David Gilmour or Roger Waters?

[Bossy Monkey]

I'm with Dave. Us doughy gargoyle-looking guys gotta stick together.

[Oeditpus Rex]

1. What are the criteria?

:shrug:

[Bossy Monkey]

2. Whatever you want them to be

Which do you like better, say.

[Oeditpus Rex]

7. Then I cannot answer

Waters' lyrics make me think, and feel, like no others. But Gilmour is an instrumental god, and no slouch as a lyricist himself.

[no name no slogan]

3. Syd Barrett

After he left, it was all downhill

[mitchum]

12. I know that it's heresy, but I actually find Barrett's work to be just...

too twee...and "oh so quaintly English" No thanks.
I think their best work is post-Syd pre-"Dark Side of the Moon"

[Initech]

4. Can I wait until "On An Island" is out tomorrow before I answer?

I really like Roger Waters' solo albums (The Pros & Cons Of Hitchhiking and Amused To Death), but I havent heard any of Gilmour's solo albums yet. That will change tomorrow!

[Bossy Monkey]

10. The poll was inspired by seeing the title track on VH2

(Ok, VH1 Classic, but VH2 makes ever so much more sense.) I was a little surprised to hear and see Crosby and Nash with Gilmour. Sounded like a pretty good record.

[GCP]

5. Gilmore was really hot when he was younger

Leonardo de Caprio could play him :D

[otohara]

8. He's Still Hot

yummy!

[mitchum]

11. A couple of years ago, my wife saw some early footage of Gilmour...

and exclaimed, "Damn, he was good looking! I can't believe he turned into that pudding-faced yob"

[Dukkha]

6. why is there no both option?

[Bossy Monkey]

9. Option 4 n/t