Best Genesis Album

[General Zod]

With Peter Gabriel, I'd have to go with The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway. With Phil Collins, I'll go with Duke.

[Rabrrrrrr]

1. Wind and Wuthering? Where's that?!

[General Zod]

2. My bad........

I forgot all about that one.

[pretzel4gore]

3. and then there were three...

wind and wuthering too....

[nytemare]

4. Lamb, Lamb, Lamb.

Lamia, that was a cool and weird song!!

[Rabrrrrrr]

5. I can't believe Abacab is getting so many votes!

It seems like there really are two different groups of Genesis fans - those who know the good, pre-Abacab stuff, and those who are the johnny come latelies who either don't understand the earlier music, or don't know it exists.


And I don't say that just because of this poll, but for many, many years that has been my impression.

And I'm one of the johnny-come-latelies - my very first rock concert was the Abacab concert, which my parents gifted me with for my 16th birthday. And it was only after I was totally blown away by those fuckin' geniuses that I started to get into their older music with the help of a friend who was also into the older musics of many bands.