Who's hotter, Elizabeth Montgomery or Mary Tyler Moore?

[kanrok]

[donheld]

1. At least Brett has the right plumbing.

:bounce::bounce:

[xmas74]

2. Brett's hot.

[doc03]

22. What's with the pronunciation

How does he get Farv out of Favray. Does it sound too French for him or what?

[Rowdyboy]

23. Cajun pronunciation....Brett's people come from

south Mississippi/Louisiana...

[xmas74]

27. He's from Mississippi.

Maybe that's how they pronounce it there. I'm not really sure.

[Salviati]

3. Mary Tyler Moore

I'm a sucker for brunettes...

[khashka]

4. Gotta go with Elizabeth.

But Brett's hot.

Khash.

[tuvor]

5. Elizabeth Montgomery, but

Laura Petrie had the hottest clothes. God blessed heterosexual men everywhere when he invented capris!

[khashka]

7. Yeah she had amazing legs

You know they took her out of capris because they found out the majority of housewives wore skirts and the public demanded she get back into 'em. So they made sure after that that she always had one scene each episode in capris?

That might be apocryphal but I've read it in lot's of places....

Khash.

[kanrok]

13. MTM was the original "desperate housewife"

She was hot. But EM was just as hot.

[TrueAmerican]

6. Since Elizabeth is dead

I would think Mary would be hotter. Mary should be about 98.6 F I think a dead person's body is not very warm.

[Lex]

12. Elizabeth Montgomery is dead?!

Damn, I missed when that happened.

[xmas74]

28. I think that she had cancer.

[autorank]

18. Comments like this make me proud to be a Raider fan. Chillin in DC...

[liontamer]

8. E.M

even though that's a weird pic of her

[kanrok]

9. I changed the pic

n/t

[liontamer]

19. good choice

[arcane1]

10. could you have picked a worse pic of Elizabeth?

she's 10 times hotter han MTM, but you'd never guess it from these choices

it's the "Dean scream" of EM pics :P

on edit- thanks! :)

[kanrok]

11. check out the new one

n/t

[Floogeldy]

14. Elizabeth had a nicer figure than your pic shows

I won't go into more detail abou tits o you figure it out for yourself.

}(

[kanrok]

Hmmm...I wonder what you're trying to communicate?

I need proof.

[Floogeldy]

21. Okay

[gristy]

15. Did Moore break her nose when she was a kid?

It's sticking way to the left in the picture. Other than that, she looks great. ;)

[edbermac]

16. Surely you jest...Elizabeth is a million times hotter...

[sendero]

17. I had a major crush...

... on Ms. Montgomery when I was a boy. Oh yeah, she is hot in a 60's sort of way.

[Osamasux]

20. There's something about Mary....

[Left Is Write]

24. Elizabeth Montgomery, but

Laura Petrie really was the ideal housewife, and I loved her clothes and the decor of her home.

[CanuckAmok]

25. Do you mean now, or then?

I'd say right now, Mary Tyler Moore is about 98 degrees hotter than Elizabeth Montgomery.

[DaveinMD]

26. I love them both

but Elizabeth. I have always loved her.

[last_texas_dem]

29. Gotta be MTM

Mary Tyler Moore was one of my first celebrity crushes, whenever Dick Van Dyke debuted on "Nick at Nite" when I was a kid. She was always nice-looking, but she was a total hottie on that show.

Not that Elizabeth Montgomery wasn't quite good-looking herself. Maybe it's just the brunette thing with me, but I think MTM is prettier/sexier.

[the_spectator]

30. EM was so HOTTTTT

Not just the way she looked, but also that sexy-sexy voice (in that mid-century WASPy way she had.)

[skypilot]

31. Interesting that you should compare these two.

Both of them were stars in a comedy series that most of us grew up watching and both of them later played roles in dramatic movies that made us see them in a completely different way. MTM, of course, did "Ordinary People" and I swear to God, that woman kinda scared me after that. EM did "The Legend of Lizzie Borden" with the same chilling effect.

[WI_DEM]

32. Part Two: Who's the hottest Dick?

Dick York, Dick Sargent or Dick Van Dyke.

[elperromagico]

33. Battle of the Dicks!

[Balbus]

34. Now or then?

Mary Tyler Moore is still looking good for her age, but I don't know about Liz. Back then I'd have to say Liz, though.

[BurtWorm]

35. That is way too difficult a choice.

For sentimental reasons, though, I guess I would settle on Mary Tyler Moore, who I was in love with throughout my childhood. I just wish she hadn't ruined it all with plastic surgery. I don't care if she aged gracefully, but I wish she'd aged naturally. (You can't age gracefully when you look like a Muppet! :cry: )

[DaveinMD]

36. this thread

is worth a second look. They were both so great.