|
He overexplains everything in such a literal manner that he leaves no magic for the audience to discover. He simply lays it down on film, like an accountant spelling out a profit/loss report. In the first movie, when McGonegal punishes Harry and crew, she tells them "The four of you will begin your detention tomorrow (or something like that)." It's very obvious to everyone that "four" includes Draco Malfoy (who is so much like Bush!), but to make sure the audience gets it, he has Malfoy say "Excuse me professor, perhaps I misheard you, but I thought you said four of us." Then McGonegal (I know I'm misspelling it) explains that he has to be punished for being out of his room, too. What could have been a clever scene turns into thirty seconds of wasted film that bores the audience. The audience got it from the first line. And for the life of me I couldn't tell if Columbus was just following the book for no reason, or whether he thought it was funny to see Malfoy's slow realization of his predicament, or if he just figured he had to lay it out in great detail because we are all morons.
Either way, he does that all through the movies, dragging scenes out with too much obvious dialogue and losing any emotional or humorous momentum the scene could have built.
The movies work, but only because of the great story and casting, not because of the directing. IMO, anyway.
That's a lot of words to claim someone else uses too many words, huh? But I've been wanting to grip about him for so long!
|