<snip>
The tone for this new gloves-off era was set by the White House itself, which has openly scorned the notion that prisoners in its "war on terror" have any rights. The whole purpose of building a special prison camp at Guantanamo Bay was clearly to put detainees beyond the reach of U.S. law.
Of course, the Geneva Conventions should have applied there; but the Bush administration simply announced that the detainees were "unlawful combatants" — a newly defined category of human being arbitrarily stripped of all legal rights by a country that, paradoxically, continued to bill itself as the world's leading democracy.
What possible reason would there be to hold prisoners in a law-free, offshore enclave except to do things to them that the law doesn't permit — including perhaps to "soften them up" before interrogations, to apply the very gloves-off treatment that Black set out to members of Congress as the new normal.
There was plenty of international outrage over this stance but, to a large extent, the U.S. media and intellectual community accepted it. http://www.smirkingchimp.com/print.php?sid=16098