Important article by BBC governor Gavyn Davies.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2003/07/27/do2701.xml&sSheet=/opinion/2003/07/27/ixop.html&secureRefresh=true&_requestid=176833Even amid the sadness surrounding the tragic death of Dr Kelly, some people in and around the Government have seen fit to place the governors of the BBC under public attack in the past few days. The dogged independence of the board in the face of intense pressure has driven some political figures close to distraction, such has been their determination to influence the editorial decisions of Britain's most trusted provider of news and current affairs. Threats, veiled and not so veiled, from "government sources" to take revenge on the BBC by reducing its funding, removing its director-general, and changing its charter have been reported frequently in the media. All this amply demonstrates why Britain still needs the tried and tested system of BBC governance to stand up to storms of this kind.
The governors of the BBC are appointed, in effect, by the Culture Secretary, following a public appointments procedure under the Nolan rules. Tessa Jowell has now appointed or re-appointed 10 of the 12 governors, including the chairman and vice-chairman. Oddly, some of the Government's friends appear to have lost confidence in the judgment and honesty of these appointees. Our integrity is under attack, and we are chastised for taking a different view on editorial matters from that of the Government and its supporters. Because we have had the temerity to do this, it is hinted that a system that has protected the BBC for 80 years should be swept away and replaced by an external regulator that will "bring the BBC to heel".
I trust that wiser heads in the Government will prevail. There is only one reason why the BBC has been able to build the trust of its audiences over so many years, and that is because it is emphatically not the voice of the state. Everyone in politics says that they would never wish to make it so, but sometimes their actions belie this. When that happens, the BBC needs its board of governors to stand up and say halt.
All of the individuals who emerge from the governors' highly competitive public appointments process have distinguished records in their fields. Although they emanate from many parts of the political spectrum, and from none, they are all aware that they must deposit their political opinions, along with their coats, outside the Governors' Council Chamber in Broadcasting House. They have many different roles in the BBC, but prime among them is to place an unshakable barrier between the BBC's editorial processes and political bullying. There is no alternative mechanism which could perform this function anything like as well as the Board of Governors.