General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsTransgender woman live-tweets her expulsion from Orlando airport
Shadi Petosky, a transgender woman, was detained unexpectedly at the Orlando airport on Monday after the TSA allegedly decided that her genitalia didn't match up to their (mis)perceptions about gender. The TSA had yet to release a statement by the time that comedian Tig Notaro tweeted to her 39,000 followers to watch Petosky's tweets.
Below is Petosky's personal account of what happened, organized from her first tweet to most recent as of publishing. She expresses frustration, confusion, and outright indignation about the treatment she received by the TSA and police officers, who asked her at one point what her sex was.
I am being held by the TSA in Orlando because of an "anomaly" (my penis)
Shadi Petosky (@shadipetosky) September 21, 2015
I would like any help I can get at the Orlando airport.
Shadi Petosky (@shadipetosky) September 21, 2015
The TSA at the Orlando Airport told me I couldn't take photos but this is denigrating. I have missed my flight pic.twitter.com/PHwBLiJ0cB
Shadi Petosky (@shadipetosky) September 21, 2015
The TSA has left me in a room alone. There is an officer holding the door. pic.twitter.com/aFA0cQxAGx
Shadi Petosky (@shadipetosky) September 21, 2015
TSA agent Bramlet told me to get back in the machine as a man or it was going to be a problem.
More: http://www.vox.com/2015/9/21/9367327/transgender-shadi-petosky-twitter-orlando-airport
shenmue
(38,506 posts)damnedifIknow
(3,183 posts)I thought people were finally getting beyond this type of crap and then this happens.
arely staircase
(12,482 posts)haikugal
(6,476 posts)icymist
(15,888 posts)Gotta protect the society from undocumented penises!
xynthee
(477 posts)damnedifIknow
(3,183 posts)Are these machines or scanners so invasive that they actually show genitalia? Yeah, I'll stick to driving.
LisaL
(44,973 posts)They are designed to see under the clothes.
blue neen
(12,319 posts)Why, indeed, is this even an issue with the TSA? It makes no sense.
Glassunion
(10,201 posts)Fuck yeah!
Arkansas Granny
(31,513 posts)and why did it matter to them? Did they see it on the body scan? Does TSA make a habit of making sure that a person's genitalia match their gender?
LisaL
(44,973 posts)backscatter712
(26,355 posts)damnedifIknow
(3,183 posts)"I heard you asked if I was a boy or a girl. I think the important thing to remember is that everyone can be anything they want to be in this world," Hnilicka said, according to her Facebook post.
"And it's also important to try to be the best selves we can be for our family and friends. And even to strangers. So to answer your question, I was told that I was a boy when I was little and now I live my adult life as a girl. It sounds complicated, but it's actually pretty simple."
Hnilicka then asked the little girl if she had any questions. The child replied, "Nope!" and flashed a smile. "
procon
(15,805 posts)never mind. Seriously, what impact does a person's genitals have on flight safety?
icymist
(15,888 posts)Last edited Mon Sep 21, 2015, 10:37 PM - Edit history (1)
eom
Baitball Blogger
(46,697 posts)But, I'm surprised that the TSA is part of the backwater culture.
icymist
(15,888 posts)After all, they have the right to practice their deeply held religious beliefs! Frankly, if everyone is comfortable with 'agents' doing this to trans-people, then it's just a matter of time before they start to find ways to do this to others they don't agree with.
Takket
(21,550 posts)disgraceful. the TSA should be looking for people with bombs and guns, not people that they think have a vagina but actually have a penis. that isn't a threat to the safety of an aircraft. The 9/11 hijackers didn't pull off their attack by pretending to be women, so why do we need to be worried about a trans person?
LostOne4Ever
(9,288 posts)[font style="font-family:'Georgia','Baskerville Old Face','Helvetica',fantasy;" size=4 color=teal]Being trans is not a crime! [/font]
mopinko
(70,070 posts)"get back in the machine as a man"
borrow a suit and tie?
flex her muscles and act like an ass?
i dont even understand that.
Spider Jerusalem
(21,786 posts)icymist
(15,888 posts)End of the world! Jesus says so. Oh wait, no she don't. Well, you don't have the right to prove that there are people different from me. So there!
damnedifIknow
(3,183 posts)Why does everyone have to look and be the same? Do we all live in Stepford?
One_Life_To_Give
(6,036 posts)I am going to speculate that they have a gender matching tech for each on the scanners. And you know being forced to see a *&^ on your scanner at work is such a traumatic experience. It's why we have dedicated male and female Paramedics, Nurses and Doctors!
philosslayer
(3,076 posts)Its the data system. The data system says she is a male. The TSA is very particular about data matching. If your middle name or birthday in the system doesn't match what is on your ID and doesn't match what is on your ticket, then you don't fly. This is an example of TSA bureaucrats mindlessly following rules.
The TSA -- another organization brought to you by George W. Bush.
MillennialDem
(2,367 posts)delayed her because of the porno scanner anomaly.
EDIT: From another article:
"Ms. Petosky said she followed T.S.A. guidelines, which say that people should travel under the name and gender that appears on their government-issued ID, but activists say the agency still subjects transgender travelers to unwanted and invasive treatment. "
Sounds like her ID was in order.
JackInGreen
(2,975 posts)I swear.....I've actually applied for the TSA, I knew there was something wiggy when I was overqualified.
crim son
(27,464 posts)Bluenorthwest
(45,319 posts)disfigure God's plan. Just consider the persons denigrated by your chosen hero. That's it. Just consider.
Arugula Latte
(50,566 posts)tblue37
(65,273 posts)pass from these yahoos because she is famous. Probably they would ask her to take pictures with them and sign autographs.
Will this society EVER emerge from the dark ages?
yeoman6987
(14,449 posts)Obviously more to be done.
ryan_cats
(2,061 posts)I didn't want to touch this last night but if she was tweeting while holding me up behind her, I would have cheered as the TSA pulled her out of line.
I'm thinking there's a bit more to the story but why would that matter as this narrative allows people to show us all how tolerant they are? So tolerant that being played isn't even on their radar. The real ire should be against GWB's TSA when they harass everyone.
gregcrawford
(2,382 posts)... I think your homophobia is showing. She was documenting her unwarranted detention, not holding anyone up. Read all the tweets at the link.
ryan_cats
(2,061 posts)My phobia is falling for media stories, unless they allow me to vent my outrage against, the MAN. Then I'm cool with it.
MohRokTah
(15,429 posts)Most people are getting over that.
Transphobia, which is something even homosexuals can suffer from.
gregcrawford
(2,382 posts)I'm an old straight guy, so I'm a little vague on proper terminology.
gollygee
(22,336 posts)If someone is actively being mistreated and making sure there's evidence of it, it isn't the person being mistreated who is the problem.
yardwork
(61,588 posts)What was she supposed to do? She kept asking them why she was being detained.
This is a serious question. If you were behind somebody who was detained by TSA and led away to a detention cell, what would you do? How would you be inconvenienced?
MADem
(135,425 posts)"Get back in the machine as a man?" Really?
I hope she recorded that!
I wonder if that "explosive residue" reason was real or not--I know if you gas up your rental before you return it, and get any gas on your hands, it can give a false reading.
HockeyMom
(14,337 posts)Last year during the Ebola scare TSA in Ft. Myers were asking little old ladies in wheelchairs if they had been to Africa on Safari recently.
Were they doing this in JFK? No, because they had far more real, serious issues to contend with. Transgender would certainly be a non issue at a major International Airport. Sorry, Orlando does not qualify as a MAJOR International Airport.
ScreamingMeemie
(68,918 posts)The advent of TSA has brought about the advent of nationwide stupidity.
MrScorpio
(73,630 posts)Thank Gawd that I never have to fly.
Omaha Steve
(99,568 posts)fbc
(1,668 posts)That's what the TSA is for, isn't it?
I don't remember them being created to police genitals.
MillennialDem
(2,367 posts)on my leg and between my legs.
They made me go through again and didn't say anything and the new image just showed a couple of dots between my legs and they let me go through.
After that I figured out they made me go through the scanner again and selected "male" instead of female. That said I don't really give a shit because they were polite and didn't say anything or ask any rude questions or detain me, but I would raise hell if they called me out publicly for it or made me miss my flight.
MynameisBlarney
(2,979 posts)I would say that I'm shocked at this display of incompetence, ignorance and insensitivity...
But, I guess that's the defacto motto of the TSA.