Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
To Boston. From Kabul. With Love. (Original Post) OneGrassRoot Apr 2013 OP
They know the pain..... lastlib Apr 2013 #1
Beautiful...thank you. CaliforniaPeggy Apr 2013 #2
... OneGrassRoot Apr 2013 #4
Thanks for posting this. Old and In the Way Apr 2013 #3
all human beings I wish I could pick up out of that shithole snooper2 Apr 2013 #13
To Boston from Kabul.... Mythos Apr 2013 #5
Welcome to DU Mythos! hrmjustin Apr 2013 #26
people can be so incredible renate Apr 2013 #6
Thank You For That !!! - K & R !!! WillyT Apr 2013 #7
Except... (and I really hate to post this) Demo_Chris Apr 2013 #8
I heard that too, about 9/11 Enrique Apr 2013 #9
Here you go.... Demo_Chris Apr 2013 #10
WOW! I didn't know this. Incredible. FourScore Apr 2013 #12
It really is amazing isn't it. That's one of those pieces of information that invites questions. nt Demo_Chris Apr 2013 #14
that's incredibly sad... but important to know renate Apr 2013 #19
I really hate to post this also, but... FourScore Apr 2013 #11
Yes, it's the same sign. nt Demo_Chris Apr 2013 #15
The literacy rate is about 11% bhikkhu Apr 2013 #16
but these specific people might know because they have contact with whoever is taking their pics JI7 Apr 2013 #17
Plus, Afghanistan is more open now than in the Taliban era. CJCRANE Apr 2013 #24
The photographer, an American woman named Beth Murphy, currently in Afghanistan, left a little note: Ola. Apr 2013 #20
Thank you, Ola, and welcome! OneGrassRoot Apr 2013 #22
Thank you for posting this. And welcome. Nt a la izquierda Apr 2013 #23
wonderful!!! Thank you for posting this. FourScore Apr 2013 #25
thank you, Ola, and welcome to DU! renate Apr 2013 #27
is this one from iraq ? JI7 Apr 2013 #18
yup. Ola. Apr 2013 #21
OneGrassRoot, you are simply awesome. :) mother earth Apr 2013 #28

lastlib

(23,191 posts)
1. They know the pain.....
Tue Apr 16, 2013, 08:34 PM
Apr 2013

WE inflicted a lot of it, and they can still do this....! Amazing!


Right back atcha, Kabul!

 

snooper2

(30,151 posts)
13. all human beings I wish I could pick up out of that shithole
Tue Apr 16, 2013, 11:20 PM
Apr 2013

and put in the house behind us that is for sale...

renate

(13,776 posts)
6. people can be so incredible
Tue Apr 16, 2013, 10:25 PM
Apr 2013

This is truly moving and inspiring. Thank you for posting this.

To Kabul from us with love...

 

Demo_Chris

(6,234 posts)
8. Except... (and I really hate to post this)
Tue Apr 16, 2013, 10:32 PM
Apr 2013

Except none of these people have the slightest idea that ANYTHING happened in Boston. They have never heard of Boston and they don't know what the sign they are holding says.

As I understand it, it is incredibly unlikely they have ever even heard of 9-11 or the twin towers. Even after all this time something like 90% of the Afghan population has never heard of this attack and has no idea what we are doing there.

Enrique

(27,461 posts)
9. I heard that too, about 9/11
Tue Apr 16, 2013, 10:53 PM
Apr 2013

I read somewhere that an average Afghan did not know what the Twin Towers were, the main thing they knew about the attack was that it meant the US was going to attack them and they were terrified of that.

 

Demo_Chris

(6,234 posts)
10. Here you go....
Tue Apr 16, 2013, 11:14 PM
Apr 2013
Most Afghans do not even know about 9/11, according to disturbing poll
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2035160/Most-Afghans-know-9-11-according-disturbing-poll.html#ixzz2QgcCB7WK

Think tank: 92% of Afghans never heard of 9/11
http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2010/11/19/think-tank-afghans-dont-know-911/


Study: Few Afghans Know About 9/11, Reason for War. 92 percent of men in key province are unaware of 2001 attacks on U.S.
https://www.commondreams.org/headline/2010/11/20

It is possible that the photographer told these people that there was a terrorist attack and the sign expressed condolences, but we will never know for sure. The photographer might have told them the sign said "Yankee Go Home!" What we DO know is that these people likely had no independent knowlege of this attack. How could they?


 

Demo_Chris

(6,234 posts)
14. It really is amazing isn't it. That's one of those pieces of information that invites questions. nt
Tue Apr 16, 2013, 11:24 PM
Apr 2013

renate

(13,776 posts)
19. that's incredibly sad... but important to know
Wed Apr 17, 2013, 03:53 AM
Apr 2013

Thanks for that very, very important information. I had no idea.

FourScore

(9,704 posts)
11. I really hate to post this also, but...
Tue Apr 16, 2013, 11:18 PM
Apr 2013

If you look through all the pictures at the link, all of the people are holding the same sign. Look at it closely. So basically, someone convinced them to hold hold a hand written sign (they couldn't even read) and they took their picture -- thereby substantiating the comment that they have probably never heard of Boston and have no idea what happened.

bhikkhu

(10,714 posts)
16. The literacy rate is about 11%
Wed Apr 17, 2013, 12:01 AM
Apr 2013

after so many decades of war. Perhaps the people in the pictures don't know how to write, but perhaps they know more about the message than we do anyway.

JI7

(89,244 posts)
17. but these specific people might know because they have contact with whoever is taking their pics
Wed Apr 17, 2013, 12:09 AM
Apr 2013

so they might be the small number of people who do get outside info.

CJCRANE

(18,184 posts)
24. Plus, Afghanistan is more open now than in the Taliban era.
Wed Apr 17, 2013, 11:31 AM
Apr 2013

TVs were banned under the Taliban.

I assume that nowadays most villages will have at least one TV and radio.

Ola.

(7 posts)
20. The photographer, an American woman named Beth Murphy, currently in Afghanistan, left a little note:
Wed Apr 17, 2013, 03:59 AM
Apr 2013

This is the story behind my photo series – To Boston. From Kabul. With Love.

When I left Boston for Afghanistan nearly 6 weeks ago, it was with some trepidation – the first I’ve felt after several filming trips here. Why now? Perhaps because the Afghanistan I’m visiting this Spring is not the same as the country I traveled to in 2001/2002, 2006 and 2009. It has experienced a decade of war, and I’ve seen firsthand how the outlook has changed among so many — from one of cautious hope for a better future to one of grim acceptance that this last painful, protracted period of violence and political upheaval may still not yield freedom from oppression in this country.

Just last week I woke up to frantic emails and texts from home after the worst insurgent attack in the country in over a decade. “Yes, I’m fine. Safe.” I wrote to family and friends, assuring them that I was far from the violence. Today, when I grabbed my phone off the bedside table, I thought I was re-reading one of my own texts: “We’re ok. And everyone we know is safe.” But instead it was a message from my husband, Dennis, assuring me that he and our 5-year-old daughter were fine. Boston. Attacked. It was – still is – hard to comprehend. Like so many others, I have experienced the pure joy – and pain – of crossing the Boston Marathon finish line, and I felt heartbroken for the victims and for our little city. I also felt a deep sense of longing to be home.

I decided I wanted to send some love from 6500 miles away. Before leaving the house, I made the sign, “To Boston / From Kabul / With Love” and planned to take one picture of me holding it. But as I talked to people here about what had happened – many had heard the news – I saw the pain in their faces, and reminders of their own hardships. They said, “I’m so sorry,” with that defining head shake that doesn’t need another word of explanation; it says, “I understand.”

Frozan Rahmani, a program officer for CARE International, was especially emotional, “Every time I hear about attacks happening – whether it’s in the United States, Pakistan, England or here, I became too sad. All those people had hopes and dreams for their futures. Their parents had hopes and dreams for their futures. It doesn’t matter that we experience this more often here. No one should experience any of it ever. It’s always the innocent who suffer.”

She paused. “I wish there was something I could do.”

“There is,” I said. “Would you be willing to hold this sign to send a little love from Kabul?”

http://principlepictures.com/blog/2013/04/17/the-story-behind-the-pictures/

renate

(13,776 posts)
27. thank you, Ola, and welcome to DU!
Sun Apr 21, 2013, 04:36 AM
Apr 2013

Here's another story about how this is for real:

"As I started to talk with people here about what was happening, I saw the expressions on their faces change," she said. "They experience things like this here all the time. You might expect that they'd be desensitized to it or talk about it with a lack of compassion, but it was the exact opposite. There was this shared experience of pain and suffering, and the way people expressed that to me was really beautiful."
Those expressions led Murphy to ask permission to photograph them holding her sign – a spontaneous idea that quickly spread around the world and went viral on the Internet.


http://worldnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/04/20/17839134-to-boston-from-kabul-with-love?lite

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»To Boston. From Kabul. Wi...