Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
14 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Silent Holocaust Memorial Day thread-Never Again is not rhetoric and not just for Israel. (Original Post) bobthedrummer Apr 2013 OP
... Mnemosyne Apr 2013 #1
But of course that doesn't really apply to dirty stinking gypos does it? TheMadMonk Apr 2013 #2
Or locations in sub-Saharan Africa HereSince1628 Apr 2013 #3
Not true. Donald Ian Rankin Apr 2013 #4
they were one of the main targets of the Holocost dsc Apr 2013 #6
Absolutely true, but isn't "never again" specifically about post-holocaust? Donald Ian Rankin Apr 2013 #7
So, because they only went back to retail murder that's OK then? TheMadMonk Apr 2013 #9
Tell me, is it the word "appalling" or the word "OK" that you don't understand Donald Ian Rankin Apr 2013 #10
Faluja, all males older than 14(?) = viable targets + kettling = genocide. TheMadMonk Apr 2013 #14
A bit late to say never again, after Cambodia and Rwanda. Donald Ian Rankin Apr 2013 #5
Kick leftynyc Apr 2013 #8
... LeftishBrit Apr 2013 #11
Very powerful and surprising song during my early teens. Socal31 Apr 2013 #12
~~~ Hekate Apr 2013 #13
 

TheMadMonk

(6,187 posts)
2. But of course that doesn't really apply to dirty stinking gypos does it?
Tue Apr 9, 2013, 02:10 PM
Apr 2013

(language chosen solely for gut punching effect)

The ongoing treatment of Romany today, is pretty much equivalent to the treament of European Jews for over a millenium.

Donald Ian Rankin

(13,598 posts)
4. Not true.
Tue Apr 9, 2013, 02:47 PM
Apr 2013

The treatment of Romany is appalling, but there have been no large scale mass murders or forced ethnic cleansing recently enough to qualify for the present tense, for one thing.

Donald Ian Rankin

(13,598 posts)
7. Absolutely true, but isn't "never again" specifically about post-holocaust?
Tue Apr 9, 2013, 04:04 PM
Apr 2013

I think that's the point of the "again"; it's too late to say "never".

 

TheMadMonk

(6,187 posts)
9. So, because they only went back to retail murder that's OK then?
Tue Apr 9, 2013, 10:29 PM
Apr 2013

And I susspect there was sufficient wholsale murder behind the Iron Curtain to put the lie to your claim.

Today crimes committed against the Romany are poorly investigated, if they are investigated at all. And crimes commited by them are disproportianately punished.

BTW: Cambodia, Vietnam, Uganda under Idi Amin, Rwanda, and right now in Iraq and Afghanistan our very own people are into genocide up to their necks.

Oh and that little place called Palestine where the Jews are slowly but surely wiping out an entire nation.

Again, Again, Again, Again.

Donald Ian Rankin

(13,598 posts)
10. Tell me, is it the word "appalling" or the word "OK" that you don't understand
Wed Apr 10, 2013, 03:40 AM
Apr 2013

In my vocabulary, the two are clearly not compatible.

Your list of genocides is at most three for seven - Rwanda and Cambodia definitely were genocides; Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan and Palestine definitely weren't/aren't; I don't know enough about Amin to be sure.

You could add Saddam Hussein's treatment of the Marsh Arabs to the list if you wanted, I believe, although I don't know enough about it to be sure.

 

TheMadMonk

(6,187 posts)
14. Faluja, all males older than 14(?) = viable targets + kettling = genocide.
Wed Apr 10, 2013, 11:31 AM
Apr 2013

Taliban are not a political party, they're as much a people in their own right as the Hutus or Tutsis, not very nice, but a people all the same. George Bush's annoucement of his intention to wipe them out was a declaration of intent to commit genocide.

Palestine: Destruction of identity; refusal of self determination; millions forced from their land and into what amount to concentration camps. Genocide.

Vietnam: Mai Lai was just the one that made headlines. There were dozens, possibly 100s of other like examples. Genocide.

You don't have to kill everyone to commit genocide, just try to destroy their collective identity.

Socal31

(2,484 posts)
12. Very powerful and surprising song during my early teens.
Wed Apr 10, 2013, 04:03 AM
Apr 2013

Most hip-hop/rap at the time, when being political, was about the plight of the American black male born into poverty.





"To all those races, colors, and creeds,
every man bleeds, for the countless victims
and all the families of the murdered, tortured and slaved,
raped, robbed and persecuted
Never Again, To the men, women, and children.
Who died in their struggle to survive,
never to be forgotten.
Reuven Ben Menachum, yo..

My own blood, dragged through the mud
Perished in my heart still cherished and loved
Stripped of our pride, everything we lived for
Families cried, there's no where to run to, no where to hide
Tossed to the side, Access denied
6 million died for what?
Yo a man shot dead in his back
Helpless women and children under constant attack
For no reason, till the next season, and we still bleeding
Yo it's freezing, And men burn in hell, some for squeezing
No hope for a remedy, nothing to believe
Moving targets, who walk with the star in their sleeve
Forever marked wit a number, tattooed to your body
Late night, eyes closed, clutched to my shotty
Having visions, flashes of death camps and prisons, no provisions
Deceived by the devils decisions, forced into a slave
Death before dishonor for those men who were brave
Shot and sent to their grave
can't awaken, it's too late, Everything's been taken,
I'm shaken, family, history, the making


Never again shall we march like sheep to the slaughter
Never again shall we sit and take orders
Stripped of our culture, robbed of our name
Raped of our freedom and thrown into the flames
Forced from our families, taken from our homes
Moved from our God then burned of our bones
Never again, never again, shall we march like sheep to the slaughter
Leave our sons and daughters, stripped of our culture
Robbed of our name
Raped of our freedom and thrown into the flames
Forced from our families, taken from our homes
Moved from our God and everything we own


Some fled through the rumors of wars
But most left were dead, few escaped to the shores
With just one loaf of bread, banished, hold in for questioning
And vanished, Never to be seen again, I can't express the pain
That was felt in the train to Auschwitz, tears poured down like rain
Naked face to face, with the master race, Hatred blood and David
My heart belongs to God and stay sacred
Rabbi's and priests, Disabled individuals
The poor, the scholars all labeled common criminals
Mass extermination, total annihilation
Shipped into the ghetto and prepared for liquidation
Tortured and starved, innocent experiments
Stripped down and carved up or gassed to death
The last hour, I smelled the flowers
Flashbacks of family then sent to the showers
Powerless undressed, women with babies clumped tight to their chest
Crying, who would've guessed -- dying, another life lost
Count the cost, another body gas burned and tossed in the holocaust"

Hekate

(90,538 posts)
13. ~~~
Wed Apr 10, 2013, 04:09 AM
Apr 2013

(hard to achieve silent reflection at DU, but yes, Never Again applies to all humanity, no matter how we fail or succeed, fail or succeed, we must not forget)

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Silent Holocaust Memorial...